ConDem bad arguments for #indyref

The Tories have produced a buzzfeed-style page for the indyref.

Cake WorldThey take their assertion that Scots are better off by £1200 per year each in the UK than we would be if independent (their figures don’t make sense, but frankly the SNP’s arguments that we’d be better off by x amount per year each don’t make sense either) and they’ve done a series of images of the things that £1200 could buy.

Both sides have tried this argument, and both sides made a hash of it, because it is a frankly silly argument. The wealth of the UK is not a cake to be sliced up and everyone given a bit. Even if Scotland were to become actually independent in March 2016, or enter a devomax arrangement set up between the Tories and the SNP as planned in the White Paper, or remains part of the UK as at present, Scotland will still have a very few very rich people, a proportion of wealthy people, and a lot of people who are horrifyingly poor.

I have no confidence that the SNP, friends to billionaires, would permit a Constitution for Scotland that would allow for greater social mobility and improvement of the lives of the poorest.

yes scotland wealthiest nation
I’d say we already do, and what difference does that make to you and me?

But I no longer have any confidence in the Labour party to do that either. (And no one ever had any confidence in the Tories, whether they call themselves Conservatives or LibDems.)

Whether under Labour or Conservative governance, a great deal effort has been invested in trying to make sure no one gets benefits they’re not entitled to, whether deliberately or by accident, even knowing this means many people don’t get benefits they are entitled to.

J K Rowling pays her taxesVery little effort by comparison is invested in ensuring that the hugely rich pay all the tax they’re supposed to. J. K. Rowling, perhaps Britain’s most notorious wealthy taxpayer, was part of the Olympic Games Opening Ceremony: but Lakshmi Mittal, Britain’s richest man, who has £12.7 billion and who pays the British government £50,000 a year to be exempted from paying any tax on his massive income, got to carry the Olympic Torch through the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea – one of 8000 “inspirational people” selected by the Olympics committee.

In 2012, the total amount of tax uncollected through non-payment or avoidance went up to £35 billion. As part of the Tory/LibDem austerity programme, HMRC had cut the staff who pursue tax evasion and non-payment.

The population of the UK was 63.23 million in 2012.

If every single penny of tax had been collected, and then redistributed equally among everyone, we’d each have had £553.53. (Parents to receive the dosh due their minor children, of course. This could lead to arguments at bedtime.)

Quantitative easing, as practiced by governments after the bank crash, involves “fixing” the economy by giving banks huge amounts of money. As has been noted, it would be more directly effective to fix the economy by giving huge amounts of money to people who will spend it immediately, boosting their local economy and thus the national economy.

What would you spend £553.53 on? Answers in comments.

Update, 6th June

Just to add to the British government’s problems:

Lego UK said it had not granted permission for the images to be used and that they were used without the company’s knowledge.

“We have requested that the images are removed due to our neutral political stance. We are a children’s toy company and therefore all of our communication is targeted towards children. People all over the world use Lego to depict stories and scenarios – some of it not to our knowledge. We maintain our position as being a politically neutral company.”


Filed under Cake, Poverty, Scottish Politics, Tax Avoidance

2 responses to “ConDem bad arguments for #indyref

  1. A holiday to somewhere with better weather than Edinburgh

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.